Review: Log Horizon

Anime: Log Horizon (Season One)

Studio: Satelight

Episodes: 25

Original Run: Oct 5, 2013 to Mar 22, 2014

Genres: Action, Adventure, Fantasy

 

Synopsis:

The popular MMORPG game Elder Tale’s latest update somehow transports thirty-thousand Japanese players into the game’s version of Japan, Yamato. They are unable to log out and are forced to cope with their impromptu imprisonment inside the game. Shiroe, a socially awkward college student and a veteran player, immediately sets out to learn the parameters of his new existence.

Log Horizon follows Shiroe as he attempts to figure out how to live in this lawless new world that is at once both familiar and strange. He acquires his own band of loyal companions as he sets about trying to establish some sort of order in the new world before it’s too late.

 

Story:

The best way to describe Log Horizon would be as disappointing. It’s not because I had any lofty expectations going in though. Sure, I wanted it to be good but I typically want all anime I watch to be good. And for the first half of this anime, it seemed like it would be better than good. But the latter half steadily went downhill while also exacerbating existing problems to make the whole into what I labeled it as – a disappointment.

Like I said, it starts out good. There are all these players trapped in a game where they have nothing to do and no way to escape. They can’t die, the food has no flavor and they have no system to ground them. This already sets an interesting premise to build a story upon and Log Horizon does succeed in this respect. The world of Elder Tale is continuously fleshed out in new and interesting ways which serve to establish the rules in the game world without dumping it on us all at once. There’s still a fair bit of talking involved but it’s not overwhelming. The activities directly related to figuring out the game world also form Log Horizon’s most entertaining arcs. From politics to raids to cooking, there are a lot of elements that are amusing as well as informative.

But the first season is split into game mechanics and slice-of-life bits, and while the former is excellent entertainment, the latter is dull enough to leech the life out of the entire story. It’s not just my distaste for slice-of-life talking here since engaging personalities can make that kind of thing work very well. But Log Horizon doesn’t have many engaging personalities out of its main cast of veteran players and the slice-of-life parts focus on thinly characterized younger ones so the end result is absolute boredom. To make matters worse, this part is what dominates towards the end of the season, culminating in a love triangle of all things. What started out as a genuinely interesting anime ends on a thoroughly bland note.

Another thing of note is that Log Horizon employs a lot of telling over showing. This doesn’t really adversely affect the world-building but it is used as a lazy method of characterization. The main victim is the protagonist Shiroe. We learn more about him from the gushing of other characters than we do from his own actions, and in some cases, the two are completely contradictory. Shiroe himself is charming enough but the show tries to build him into this epic figure and fails rather miserably.

In short, Log Horizon is one of those shows that have a lot of good things going for it but is ultimately betrayed by its own clumsy storytelling. I finished season one with only a little pain but less than ten episodes into season two was all I could stomach.

 

Characters:

There are a large number of characters in Log Horizon and naturally, the majority of them aren’t more than pretty faces and forgotten names. But for the most part, the show splits its attention between veteran players including Shiroe and a group of younger players. As I’ve already stated, the parts including the veterans are interesting while those that focus on the younger ones don’t measure up. This is because Shiroe and the rest are involved with matters that will define their very existence in the new Elder Tale. They form a government body, make laws, establish order and go on diplomatic missions. There’s scant action but when those moments are there, it’s fun. Meanwhile, the younger and newer players are only just figuring out their own limits and forming their own bonds. It’s necessary for them to do but not that great to watch. It doesn’t help that the experienced players have more dynamic personalities.

Shiroe, a grad student with a head for strategy, is the main character. The story goes out of its way to show us how amazing he is but is only half-successful in the process. Shiroe’s main advantage is that he’s very intelligent and a famed strategist even within the game. He’s not a frontline fighter but rather the man manipulating from the shadows. And all of his triumphs in the story are also the nature of calculation and manipulation. It serves to establish him as an interesting character who can be quite cunning while remaining oblivious about his own darker leanings. The problem is that the story tries to ram Shiroe’s awesomeness down our throats with multiple characters just standing around talking about how awesome he is. Instead, they could have continued to show us that.

Shiroe’s companions include his old friends from the game, Naotsugu and Nyanta, as well as a former associate turned guildmate, Akatsuki. Naotsugu is an out and proud pervert who takes the time to randomly insert panties and breasts into every conversation. When he’s not the victim of these pitiful attempts at humor, he’s portrayed as a pleasant, supportive guy. Nyanta is a self-proclaimed gentlecat who takes purring very seriously, can cook like a champ and has no personality outside of being the nice, wise older guy. Akatsuki, on the other hand, has a personality but it revolves around Shiroe. She revolves around Shiroe. We never really learn much about her other than that she really likes Shiroe.

Other notable characters includes Crusty, leader of a combat guild who looks gentle and acts the part but also displays an unnerving amount of bloodlust in battle. He seems smart enough to give Shiroe a run for his money and is quite charismatic in general. Then there’s Lenessia, a princess among the people populating the game. She’s a quirky girl who’s fed up with the demands of her noble status and would rather just laze around. She also has a strong moral center and a (mostly hidden) spine of steel to go with it, effectively making her one of the more complex characters in the show. Unfortunately, she’s not explored much after her initial arc.

There are others but none are worth mentioning, not even the antagonists who range from being too pathetic to be effective to having too little presence to warrant much thought.

 

Art and Music:

Log Horizon’s art is good in that it’s passable without being remarkable. The character deigns, monster designs and backgrounds show enough variety to establish a unique visual impression. The animation during the fight sequences involves a lot of the typical slashing and flashy lights, each of which is handled competently. But all in all, Log Horizon is not memorable on a visual level.

There is only one OP, database by MAN WITH A MISSION and it’s certainly catchy. It is a nice piece that mixes Japanese and English and I rarely felt the need to skip it. The ending theme, Your song* by Yun*chi, on the other hand, is mediocre at best.

 

Verdict:

Don’t go into this expecting much. It may seem good at the beginning but that’s not going to last.

Rating: 5/10

Advertisements

About D

Just another avid anime fan.
This entry was posted in Anime, Log Horizon and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to Review: Log Horizon

  1. Rocco B says:

    Of course Naotsu is a nice and supportive guy; he’s the flippin main tank in the party!.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. railgunfan75 says:

    Log horizon is a show which really divides people into two camps. You either love it or you are incredibly bored by it. I personally loved it but I can understand why people wouldn’t. It certainly goes a different path than many other series. I can also agree with some of the points you make. When the show focuses on the younger players, it’s not as good. I also would agree that the animation is nothing spectacular as well. A well written thoughtful assessment- thanks for sharing your viewpoint on this series.

    Liked by 3 people

    • D says:

      At first, I thought I was going to love it but unfortunately, that didn’t last. But it still had enough fun parts that I’m not sad I gave it a go. Thanks for dropping by and giving the review a chance. I know it’s not fun to hear negatives about a show you like.

      Liked by 1 person

      • railgunfan75 says:

        It was my pleasure to read your review. I personally enjoy reading differing opinions and you have legitimate reasons for not loving the show which I can certainly respect. Seeing a viewpoint other than yours makes you think about things a little more especially when it is argued as well as your review was.

        Liked by 1 person

    • Adam says:

      It’s funny, I tend to have a very “middle of the road” reaction to it. I think it has some nice elements, which get bogged down by the execution of later arcs and the shift in focus to slice of life. The second episode is probably one of my favorites, good ole dungeon crawl.

      Liked by 2 people

      • railgunfan75 says:

        Then I stand corrected on my comment then. I honestly had not heard a middle of the road opinion on the series. Of course, your assessment is also a fair one and I won’t insist that you are wrong or anything like that. Thank you for sharing your viewpoint with me.

        Liked by 2 people

      • Adam says:

        No worries. I could be a minority. I don’t often feel like I love/hate things, but that’s just me.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Adam says:

    I have very mixed feelings about this series. On the one hand, this feels like a very interesting experiment, a “trapped in the game” series that focuses on setting and social construction, where most have a clear opposition and goal. I applaud the experiment, but I tend to agree that the series has some fairly glaring weak points.

    More than most series Log Horizon feels very fragmented. The arcs gradually move away from the standard “dungeon crawl” and become much more administrative. At times I found myself wishing more episodes required the strong veteran players to openly fight either monsters or other players to resolve a goal.

    In some ways I think the novelty of the series made me enjoy it more than others, but I don’t “love it”. I will say, most anime overly simplify their magic systems. I really liked how this series used spells with specific pros and cons, often binding or weakening an enemy for a specific window of time, in contrast with the simple “energy blast” damage. Similarly I liked how characters like Naotsugu can take a lot of damage, while the one who deals a lot of damage often suffers from a low defense, in contrast with other series where a character has both strong defense and offense.

    Liked by 1 person

    • D says:

      The experiment aspect, as you put it, was also a favorite part of mine. That plus the way they developed the in-game world gave us some of the best parts of this anime. But yeah, eventually the arcs just got duller and duller and all excitement died a sad death. I can’t comment on season 2 though.

      I have no experience with gaming so I don’t know how magic and attacks work in actual MMORPGs but I too enjoyed how Log Horizon set solid rules and explained why each spell worked as it did.

      In the end, there are some good parts to Log Horizon but the overall impression is underwhelming.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. WeekendOtaku says:

    Hmm… this purchase is looking more and more dubious the longer I put off watching this show. It just seemed too cheap during the Sentai sale to pass up 😦

    I generally like seeing attention given to world building, but it looks like where Log Horizon succeeds at this it really drops the ball with characterization. Almost nothing about your review seemed to indicate there was something to look forward to there, so I’m hoping it’s not as bad as it sounds.

    Liked by 1 person

    • D says:

      Yikes. It’s probably not as bleak as I made it sound? Okay, it kind of is but it’s likely that you still may find something worthwhile in it. For all my complaints, I don’t regret watching this since there were some really fun bits at the beginning.

      That said, I have an article about to be posted on my biggest issue with Log Horizon’s characterization (its female characters are handled horribly) so I guess I’m not done complaining yet.

      Liked by 1 person

      • WeekendOtaku says:

        Haha, yeah, from what you said here it sounds like the series really suffers in that aspect. It’s a shame, really, since the MMO setting really lends itself to having a lot more females that could stand as good characters on their own.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. raistlin0903 says:

    Phew…I am breathing a sigh of relief here. I had almost bought this one at Animecon this weekend, but in the end decided not too. The story sounded a bit too much like Sword Art Online, so I am glad I passed up on this one after reading this review.
    Still, it’s too bad really, especially seeing that it had potential when the whole thing started. But I am not really in a hurry to watch this one now (no I haven’t bought it, but I see it’s on Crunchyroll as well ). Well, at least you got another great review out of it. 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    • D says:

      Before I watched the show, I saw it described as a better version of SAO. Now I haven’t seen SAO so I can’t comment on that but Log Horizon left me distinctly unimpressed. It started out so good too :/

      I wouldn’t suggest that you bump this up on your watch encyclopedia, no. But if you ever do, I’d be interested in knowing your thoughts. This series does seem to have quite a few fans.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Remy Fool says:

    I enjoyed it at times but there certainly was a lot of telling instead of showing. The arc focusing on the little kids was also rather boring. Guess I shouldn’t feel like I have to start season 2 any time soon, huh?

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

    Liked by 1 person

    • D says:

      I liked parts of it too, particularly at the beginning but by the time it ended, I was thoroughly done. And nope, no hurry!

      Thanks for dropping by 😀

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s